Review by LarryG 2 stars out of 4
In his few years as Nirvana's drummer, Dave Grohl learned from the
master, Kurt Cobain, about mixing rock noise and melody. His first
record with his band Foo Fighters showed his ability to blend pop and
rock. While the tunes weren't quite up to Nirvana's level, Grohl had
an anger that gave the songs a good Nirvana type edge and he also
established a distinctive personality. On the band's subsequent CDs,
The Color and The Shape and the new There is Nothing Left to Lose,
Grohl has got even better at mixing pop and rock and his songs have
more form than on the debut, but the edge has been missing. Grohl has
an easy facility for making music. He can write songs with great
twists and interesting allusions to 60's pop but the other side of his
facility is that his music can seem too easy or facile.
There is Nothing Left to Lose is an uneven work but it does have
one great song and quite a few good ones. The single, Learn to Fly, is
irresistable. It hooks you in so many ways. Grohl's electric guitar
riff propels Learn to Fly from the start. The echoing sound with
Taylor Hawkins' great, crisp drums brings to mind a PhiI Spector
production. The chorus, about all the new things Grohl is looking for,
soars with Grohl's exuberant vocals. The lyrics get a little confused
later in the song when Grohl asks his love to give him "one last try"
and fly with him but Grohl's enthusiasm and energy keeps the song
buoyant. Sadly, none of the other songs on There is Nothing Left to
Lose are as well developed and exhilarating as Learn To Fly but there
are a few other enjoyable rockers. Generator has a cheesy Peter
Frampton type vocoder guitar effect but it is a fun, driving song.
Breakout is a mindless rant by Grohl about his therapist but it's a
good intense rock song like Color and the Shape's Monkey Wrench.
Nichols' beat keeps the song moving. Headwires has a riff like Gary
Numan's Cars or a Rush song. It sounds a little like an uneasy mix
between Everlong and Walking After You but it has a good trippy,
restrained feel on the verses and then rocks out nicely on the
choruses.
There is Nothing Left Left to Lose also has quite a few
stinkers. Maybe it's a reflection of his depressed state but There is
Nothing Left to Lose is low on Grohl's specialty: catchy, hard rocking
songs. Stacked Actors has pretentious, spoken verses and stupid yelled
hard rock choruses. Gimme Stitches is an uninteresting classic rocker.
Live In Skin is pointless, ponderous rock with Grohl singing what
sounds like "I'm a mountain." M.I.A. starts interestingly then bogs
down in repetition. The lyrics, like on much of the record, are self
pitying and not particularly interesting.
After Grohl had a hit with the nice, subtle Big Me from the
band's first record, there have been more slow songs on the subsequent
Foo Fighters records. With his yearning vocals and mastery of layered
Beatles or Beach Boys style pop, Grohl can make good personal pop. On
There is Nothing Left to Lose, Aurora is too sprawling and never goes
anywhere. But Next Year is well made pop with a good, clear sound. It
has the theme of many of the songs that Grohl's just going through a
bad time but soon he'll be back with his love and everything will be
O.K. Next Year starts with an acoustic guitar then builds nicely,
ending with Beatlesque strings. Ain't It the Life also has a good
dreamy feel.
There is Nothing Left to Lose has quite a few good songs but
too often Dave Grohl doesn't use his talent to make interesting,
enjoyable music.
|