Review by LarryG 3 stars out of 4
The White Stripes' White Blood Cells was one of the most
compelling CDs of 2001. The White Stripes are Jack and Meg White, a
brother and sister(if you believe them) or former romantic couple(if
you believe the rock press) from Detroit. Guitar player Jack and
drummer Meg are White Stripes' only musicians. Even with only two
musicians, White Stripes create an exciting rock sound. Working in
styles that range from headbanger rock to sensitive singer/songwriter
pop, idiosyncratic Jack throws out one catchy short song after
another. White Blood Cells overflows with hooks and Jack White's
bizarre but strangely likable personality. It's always interesting.
On White Blood Cells, Jack White comes across as an unpolished,
talented weirdo bursting with ideas. He cultivates the image of the
lone guitar fanatic, opening the CD on Dead Leaves and the Dirty
Ground sounding like a high school kid jamming through a cheap amp,
playing a riff that sounds that the one from Chicago's 25 or 6 to 4 or
maybe Ziggy Stardust. When Meg's drums kick in, Jack's still jamming
on basic power chords and sounding, with his thin, quavery voice, like
he's a kid doing a bad Bowie impression, but he's making a big guitar
sound. Jack's writing is simple but it has a fresh perspective,
simultaneously communicating eccentricity and pure romantic
attraction. He sings that it's "dead leaves and the dirty ground when
I know you're not around, shiny tops and soda pops when I hear your
lips make a sound."
Jack White likes to play the rock guitar god. He slowly crunches
power chords on Expecting while he rants about a woman who controls
him to the extent that she can order him away to Toledo. But White
never stays in a musical idiom for too long, so he immediately follows
with the very simple Little Room(which White Stripes put in the middle
of Fell In Love With A Girl to stretch out the song when they played
Letterman). Little Room has no guitar and only Meg's cymbals to
accompany Jack's short message about success: once you move from your
little room to a bigger room "you might have to think of how you got
started sitting in your little room." The Union Forever slowly plows
forward so you can feel Jack's pain as he shrieks, "there is no true
love" but in the middle, he goofily throws in a long quote from a
scene(the same one quoted by a Simpsons episode) from Citizen Kane. On
Offend In Every Way, Jack keeps the notes, chords and rhymes simple as
he sadly relates that "no matter what I do, no matter what I say", he
offends. Alternating between a spanish guitar riff and pounding
chords, Jack sounds Iike he's being silly on I Think I Smell A Rat but
he's apparently dead serious as he, with a sentiment like The
Replacements expressed on Bastards Of Young, decries kids "using your
mother and father for a welcome mat." White Blood Cells generally
provides its indulgent rock jamming in small doses or gives it fun
touches. The CD only really tests my patience at the 3/4 mark with the
instrumental(except for yelled aahs) Aluminum, which experiments
annoyingly with a trail of heavily amped, slowly played rock guitar
notes and feedback, and the fairly routine rock bravado("who do you
think you're messing with girl?") of I Can't Wait, which is only of
interest to me when he starts to sound like a pissed off John Lennon.
I prefer the Lennon similarity on This Protector. Jack, accompanied
only by his basic piano, sings about how weird it is, considering the
"many thoughts inside my head", when he has to take the role of
protector for someone even more prone to weird imaginings than he is.
White Blood Cells is often a lot of fun. Hotel Yorba is a buoyant
raveup with Jack's straining but joyful voice and a loose melody like
Subterranean Homesick Blues' or Country Joe singing "1,2,3 what are we
fighting for". Jack White loves a big, slow hard rock sound but he
also knows how to make a perfect no frills pop song. Clocking in at
1:45, Fell In Love With A Girl is still a complete rock experience.
Banging on his guitar fast and loud and screaming about a girl with
"red hair with a curl", White recalls the spirit of early rock by
stripping away any excess to find a pure rock essence. He also evokes
the giddiness of new love as he sings about the thrill of ignoring the
left brain's message that love is fleeting. Meg White's drumming is
basic but it effectively matches the simple, rambunctious sound. Jack
doesn't use any of his vocal mannerisms on Now Mary, a 60s style mod
rocker, as he invites his "mate" to even things up by disappointing
him after he let her down. Jack unleashes galloping guitar lines over
Meg's cymbal crashes.
Jack White likes hard rockers and fast, poppy fun but two of my
favorite songs on White Blood Cells are ballads in the tradition of
sincere yet self mocking, unsteady voiced artists like The Kinks' Ray
Davies and Pavement's Stephen Malkmus. For someone who can come across
as weird and glib, White's writing can be surprisingly poignant. On
The Same Boy You've Always Known, White shyly talks to a girl,
admitting "I guess I haven't grown." The power chords kick in but
White's sad defeatism continues and he concludes: "if there's anything
good about me, I'm the only one who knows." White is particularly
comfortable working from a child's perspective. Idealizing youth,
White sweetly sings on We're Going To Be Friends about innocently
spending time with a girl from school, finding bugs, walking to school
"all by ourselves" and having a teacher mark "our heights against the
wall."
The only recent band I know of who makes a rock sound as big as
The White Stripes' with only a guitar player and a drummer are Local
H. But White Stripes' songs and personality blow away Local H. Jack
White is sometimes annoying when he expresses his harder rocking
impulse but he's generally a fascinating character with interestingly
diverse musical tastes. White Blood Cells is unpredictable and fun.
|