| Reviewer Roundup |
| 1. |
 | Andrew Hicks |
 | review follows |
 |  |
| 2. |
| Dragan Antulov |
| read the review |
|    |
|
Review by Andrew Hicks
½ star out of 4
Among the ranks of 50's science-fiction movies,
FORBIDDEN PLANET is considered to be one of the best, which
makes me more determined than ever to stay away from the other
ones. You can tell from the first minute what quality entertainment
the movie holds, as a giant pie-plate flying saucer on a string flies
by and the narrator tells us that, by the year 2200, space colonization
will have spread out to other solar systems.
That's where Captain Adams (Leslie Nielson) and his crew
come in. They've been sent out to check on a mission that hasn't
been heard from in twenty years. And when they get to the
atmosphere of this coincidentally Earth-like planet, a voice on the
radio warns them to stay away. They don't, of course, landing the
pie plate to find a giant robot waddling toward them. It's Robbie the
Robot ("As Himself," the opening credits inform us), who looks like
a giant jukebox with human legs. "Do you speak English?" Robbie
asks them. "If not, I speak over 187 languages and their various
dialects and subtexts." A stone-faced Nielson replies, "Colloquial
English will do just fine, thank you."
Robbie leads them to his master, the morbid Dr. Morbius
(Walter Pidgeon), the only inhabitant of the planet. Or is he? Out
walks his beautiful daughter, Alta (Anne Francis), who was born
during the one year timeframe before some mysterious, unseen force
killed off all the colonists except for Pidgeon, who was "immune."
Now he and his daughter are living with the robot, who does all the
housework, can create any substance and has the strength to topple
a house.
No, he's not a dangerous monster that's going to terrorize
the crew (that comes later), he has a "built-in safety device" that
prevents him from killing people. Morbius demonstrates by asking
Nielson if he can borrow "that formidable-looking sidearm of yours"
and ordering Robbie to shoot Nielson with it, an order the robot
cannot compute. Seems like an amazing piece of machinery, right?
But, as Morbius tells Nielson and his space crew, "Don't attribute
feeling to him, gentlemen. Robbie is simply a tool." With no men
on the island for Alta to chase after, you have to wonder if that
last phrase has more than one meaning.
Don't think me a pervert, because we're given more than
ample evidence that Alta is sex-starved. When she sees Nielson's
men, she announces seductively, "You're lovely." And the feeling
is more than mutual, as the Lieutenant replies, "From over here, the
view looks like heaven," right in front of her father. (Lucky for him
Morbius can't order the robot to shoot him with the formidable-
looking sidearm.)
The subplot involving Alta's naivete involving men and
the men's innate horniness involving her continues for a while, as
the bad Lieutenant gets her to kiss him under the pretense that it's
a healthy Earth custom, after which she says, "There must be
something seriously the matter with me because I haven't noticed
the least bit of stimulation," quite an ego blow to the poor
Lieutenant.
It's Nielson she has the hots for, which she realizes after he
chews her out for putting all his men in such a sorry state. "I am in
command of eighteen competitively-selected, super-perfect physical
specimens with an average age of 24.6 who have been locked up for
376 days," he bellows, ordering her to put on something a little less
revealing. And apparently, it's not just the humans who are drawn
to Alta. She has the wild animals under her control and even Robbie
the Robot looks a little flustered after she calls him several times
before he finally waddles in, apologizing for his tardiness by
admitting, "I was giving myself an oil job." What a dipstick.
The movie continues with a predictable revelation -- the
planet was once inhabited by an advanced race of people who
perfected advanced technologies but were exterminated by that
unseen force, which also attacks Nielson and his crew, who shoot
back a few animated phasers at it. Throughout the movie, the music
score buzzes with other-worldly music that makes even the cheapest
Casio keyboards sound symphonic. The special effects are bad even
for that time and you already know what the dialogue is like. Suffice
it to say, the acting is just as laughable. Leslie Nielson is almost as
funny in this serious role as SPY HARD and the NAKED GUN
movies combined.
FORBIDDEN PLANET should be forbidden on this planet.
Copyright © 1996 Andrew Hicks
|