|
All-Reviews.com Movie/Video Review
Courage Under Fire
|
  out of 4
 Review by Dragan Antulov 1½ stars out of 4
|
Technology and training might be perfected to new and
unimaginable levels, but mistakes happen. In the latest war not so
insignificant number of Americans has died from the hand of their
comrades in the "friendly fire" incidents. One of such incidents occurs
at the beginning of COURAGE UNDER FIRE, 1996 war drama
directed by Edward Zwick. On February 25th 1991, during the first
Gulf War, Lt. Colonel Nathaniel Serling (played by Denzel
Washington) leads his tank unit into assault on Iraqi positions. In the
confusion of battle he takes out one of his own tanks, killing a crew
that includes his best friend. Six months later he is burdened with
guilt and tries to find solace in alcohol. His superior General
Hirschberger (played by Michael Moriarty) gives him seemingly
routine task. During the war Captain Karen Walden (played by Meg
Ryan), medivac helicopter pilot, has died while rescuing American
servicemen trapped behind Iraqi lines. She is about to become first
woman posthumously receiving Medal of Honour, and White House
wants to make public spectacle out of it. Serling must conduct formal
investigation. His interviews with surviving members of Walden's
crew, however, reveal differing accounts of the incident and Serling
starts doubting Walden's heroic conduct. In the meantime, Pentagon
and White House put a pressure on him, demanding quick end of the
investigation, but Serling is determined to establish truth whatever
the cost.
In light of certain events idea of young pretty blondes being war
heroes doesn't look like Hollywood fantasy any more, so COURAGE
UNDER FIRE is going to be more believable now than it was seven
years ago. For director Edward Zwick this fictional story was another
opportunity to explore the territory similar to his 1989 epic GLORY -
role of minorities in American military history (blacks in American
Civil War, women in Gulf War). For Meg Ryan this was opportunity
to shed her image of romantic comedies queen and play some serious
role for a change. Her task is even more complicated because she has
to play different versions of the same character. She does it well, but
the real star of the film is, of course, Denzel Washington. His regal
presence and his character story is in the end more interesting than
the story of Walden, because we know its ultimate outcome.
The biggest problem for COURAGE UNDER FIRE is in its ambition.
The movie was obvious tailored for "Oscars", and Zwick tries to give
extra dimension to otherwise simple story by modelling the main
plot around Kurosawa's RASHOMON. Unfortunately, unlike in
Japanese classic, different perspectives of truth mean very little - the
movie faithfully observes unofficial rules of modern Hollywood.
Since Walden happens to be woman in man's world, we know that
she would end up like hero. And even troubled protagonist would be
able to exercise his demons, in a scene that puts the traumatic event
from the beginning of the film into different light. Because of that,
viewers might feel cheated - they have expected thought-provoking
exploration of realities of modern warfare and instead got
Hollywood fairytale. Recent events show that some wars might
indeed look like fairytales, but tell that to people who ended up on
the wrong side of "friendly fire".
Copyright © 2003 Dragan Antulov
|
|
|
|


Buy movie posters!
|