"Hanging Up" is not the worst movie I have ever seen, but it is the only one
I can think of that made me want to pull out a gun and start shooting at the
images onscreen. It's a horrible experience, as if somebody had discovered my
pet peeves and decided to devote a whole film to winding me up. Although I
own a cellphone and am acquainted with whiny women, they are both things I
detest, and for emergencies only. Watching them for 95 minutes is not my idea
of a good time.
The film is supposed to be the story of a man's family reacting to his
descent into death. It's actually just an irritating bunch of phone
conversations between three witless sisters, who might actually develop
personalities if they cancelled their AT&T subscriptions and lived in the
real world. Meg Ryan plays Eve, the one who stays by her father's hospital
bed, deals with his eruptions of dementia, and calls up everyone else, trying
to get them to visit him. Maddy (Lisa Kudrow), the youngest sibling, is an
insecure little tramp who complains that nobody will take her seriously; she
doesn't think it odd that at age 29 she was still dreaming of becoming a rock
star, and in her mid-30s she expects she's going to be an actress. Georgia
(Diane Keaton), the eldest, is smarmy, dishonest and lies about her personal
life when it will bring her gain.
So much of "Hanging Up" takes place on the phone, with the annoying trio
barking insipid platitudes down receivers, that when I left the cinema my
ears were still ringing from clicks, beeps and dial tones. Perhaps this movie
was inevitable, such is contemporary society's obsession with
telecommunication. Delia and Nora Ephron, who wrote the screenplay, and Diane
Keaton, the director, seem to think this presentation of people is normal,
and that's rather sad.
Worse is the grating nature of the performances. Keaton plays her detestable
character with the kind of glee that shoves right into our faces and makes us
want to scream. Ryan is unconvincing, because she uses the same disorganised
comic presence as in "When Harry Met Sally" and "Joe Versus the Volcano", and
expects it to work when her character is supposed to be a cornerstone of
emotional stability. As for Lisa Kudrow, well, she's a joke, who exudes
stupidity from all of her phoney body, dead eyes, and flat, sarcastic whimper
of a voice.
You know when you're on a crowded train, and you're wedged into the window
seat when three other people need to sit in the same booth as you? "Hanging
Up" is a lot like that, as long as the three people are vapid yuppie bitches
whining and crying about their boyfriends and families into mobile telephones
that play a little tune when they ring. This is a film that could get
Gandhi's blood boiling. If it becomes your wife's favourite video, no sane
jury will convict you of domestic abuse.
Copyright © 2000 UK Critic