Protagonist of the film is Dempsey (played by Christopher Reeve), superb police detective who is loving father and caring husband. Family considerations, on the other hand, don't prevent his brother Nick (played by Edward Kerr) from having an affair with Dempsey's wife Gail (played by Kim Cattrall). One day, during a routine bust, Dempsey is shot and paralysed. Knowing that he would have to spend the rest of his life in a wheelchair, Dempsey decides to commit suicide and provide for his family in the process. He approaches Gail and Nick and asks them to help him in his plan to end his life by staging his suicide as apparent murder. Motivated less by compassion and more by huge insurance policy, adulterous couple decides to participate only to find themselves as targets of Dempsey's diabolical scheme. Dempsey has committed a perfect crime, but his former colleague Rhineheart (played by Joe Mantegna) is convinced that the apparently helpless cripple, who happens to be the most experienced homicide investigator, staged the whole thing. But proving his suspicions is going to be much harder than he has anticipated.

The script, which was written by Jerry Lazarus, Steven Schachter and actor William H. Macy (who plays the role of prosecutor in the film) had some potential. However, suspension of disbelief, necessary for viewers to enjoy this film, is forever marred by the real-life events that put the entire plot of the film into completely different perspective. But this is not the only problem of ABOVE SUSPICION. Director Schachter is not able to make his mind whether to make this film as straightforward thriller, police action film or courtroom drama. Genre confusion is not much helped by low budget that makes this film look much cheaper than it should be. Great performances by Reeve and Joe Mantegna as relentless investigator aren't reason enough to watch this routine product of cable television. In the end, ABOVE SUSPICION is a film that could be recommended only to those who want to satisfy their morbid curiosity.