| Reviewer Roundup |
| 1. |
 | Harvey Karten |
 | review follows |
 |    |
| 2. |
| Steve Rhodes |
| read the review |
|    |
|
Review by Harvey Karten
3 stars out of 4
I remember a heart-wrenching picture taken by a war correspondent in 1945,
something that won a Pulitzer or, if not, should have. The shot showed the last
American chopper out of Saigon which seems to have lifted off a minute or so
before the victorious Communist forces smashed the gates of the American Embassy
to wrap up the war, our country's first defeat ever. A handful of Vietnamese
seemed to be hanging on to the ladder after the machine got airborne, looking
like stunt men out of a Jerry Bruckheimer production. We rescued of the people
loyal to the American forces, in this case those who were working in the U.S.
Embassy. But what happened to them later, and what happened to the tens of
thousands of Vietnamese refugees who escaped, leaving everything behind, often
including their parents or siblings? Now we have the answer in what I believe
is the first motion picture to deal with the ways American ingenuity made
invention out of the Vietnam necessity. Turns out that the principal place to
relocate the Vietnamese refugees was Camp Pendleton in California, just one
example of the desert-like areas used to pitch tents and Quonset huts to keep
these folks until American sponsors could be found to give them housing. One of
the ironic points made by Timothy Linh Bui's film–which takes off like a
docu-drama but gradually and patiently builds steam to become a melodramatic
commentary on the evils of war–is that lots of these people pitched in
rudimentary tents, lining up for fried fish (which they didn't go for) and fried
chicken (better), were actually afraid of leaving the camp and going out into
the vast American arena under the sponsorship of kind families who more or less
adopted them. The devil they knew was better than the devil they didn't.
But `Green Dragon' is not primarily a puff piece for this country's
humanitarianism. In fact as more than one resident points out, America
abandoned its friends in Vietnam (which recalls the arguments made by Cubans
living in Florida that President Kennedy abandoned them at the Bay of Pigs
invasion by withdrawing the promised air support). Whether the U.S. could have
won the war, presumably by escalating the violence, is not the subject of the
picture. Instead Bui, employing a story that he co-wrote with his brother Tony,
looks at life in the refugee camp from the point of view of the Vietnamese. This
in itself makes the project laudatory.
There is much here to compare with Tony Bui's more dramatic, opened-up film,
`Three Seasons,' also a multi-character tale, that one taking place in today's
Saigon where among the stories to be told are those of a poor boy trying to
survive in the streets, a bicycle-taxi driver who falls in love with a hooker,
and an American soldier (played by Harvey Keitel) who returns to Saigon to look
for his daughter and redeem himself for his past. One of the stories in `Green
Dragon' is of the friendship between a solitary volunteer cook, Addie (Forest
Whitaker), who was injured in the war, and a ten-year-old boy who had to leave
Vietnam without his mother. The boy, understandably anxious and sad although
hopeful of an eventual reunion with his `mere,' is a fan of Mighty Mouse comic
books and through that medium, Addie gets to connect with the kid (Trung
Nguyen), teaching him to paint a canvas. What the little boy (chosen from among
500 non-professionals who tried out for the role) does not know is that his
bi-lingual uncle Tai (Don Duong), who is the camp manager appointed by the
ruling Staff Sergeant Lance (Patrick Swayze), was compelled to leave the lad's
mom in Vietnam because there were not enough seats on the aircraft out of the
country. The guilt felt by Tai is shared by Lance, who encouraged his brother
to sign up for duty in the ‘nam only to hear of the young man's death in battle
shortly thereafter.
In another story, a married woman (Hiep Thi Le) meets up with her first love
(Billinjer Tran), but her reunion is a bitter one because of a conflict that
could easily have become a template for soap-opera melodrama.
There are plenty of war movies to choose from. `Windtalkers' is in town now,
featured as a summer movie. But few develop the more mundane tales, dramatic in
their own way, about the day-to-day dealings with the by-products of these wars.
(Mark Jonathan Harris's `Into the Arms of Strangers: Stories of the Kinder
transport,' as one example, takes us into a hitherto unexplored area: the
efforts to place Jewish children from Germany, Austria and Czechoslovakia out of
harm's way during the early stages of World War II by putting them into British
homes.) While `Green Dragon' is not as absorbing as Tony Bui's `Three
Seasons'–its location completely within Camp Pendleton does not give
photographer Kramer Morgenthau the exotic scenery to explore on location in a
teeming city like Saigon–Timothy Linh Bui's effort is a poignant, worthwhile,
sincere look at how America wrested a few small victories out of its major
defeat.
Copyright © 2002 Harvey Karten
|