Review by Dragan Antulov
2 stars out of 4
In 1970s skyrocketing crime rates and apparent inability of
liberal state to clamp them down created popular sentiment
reflected in the films about Dirty Harry and Paul Kersey.
That sentiment also found its way towards comic books, and
that resulted in the futuristic superhero Judge Dredd,
featured in the very popular series published in British
magazine 2000 AD. After two decades Judge Dredd, like many
other comic book heroes, became adapted to the screen. In
1995 that particular task was given to the young British
director Danny Cannon.
The plot is set in the future where the entire planet turned
into radioactive wasteland. The surviving humans live in
overpopulated megalopolises with skyrocketing crime rates.
In order to fight crime, the authorities created Judges -
law enforcers authorised to act as judge, jury and
executioners and thus bring instant justice to any criminal
they apprehend. The best among them is Dredd (played by
Sylvester Stallone), favourite of the old Judge Fargo
(played by Max von Sydow). One day, however, Dredd is
accused of the murder he didn't commit. All the evidence
point towards him and he is sentenced to prison. While he
plots an escape, hoping to clear his name and bring the real
perpetrator the justice, Mega-City One becomes the target of
vicious political intrigue.
Fans of the original comic books have all the reasons to be
displeased with this film. Fascist overtones of the original
were too much for "politically correct" 1990s and the
character of Dredd in Disney's screen got his violence toned
down and his personality became kinder and gentler, with a
sense of humour and comic relief in the form of petty
criminal (played by Rob Schneider). The plot of the film is,
of course, formulaic and utterly predictable. However,
Sylvester Stallone fits this part quite nicely, as well as
Armand Assante, who obviously had a lot of fun playing the
over-the-top villain. Director Cannon, on the other hand,
isn't particularly interested in story and characters -
entrusted with huge budget, he probably felt like a kid in
the candy store and that reflected in truly stunning visuals
and whole series of spectacular and very attractive action
scenes. But the best thing about Cannon was his sense of
pace - films unfolds very quickly and in 90 minutes we have
hardly a time to notice one-dimensionality of the
characters, predictability of the plot and some obviously
disinterested actors (like Diane Lane in formulaic role of
female Judge). As a result, JUDGE DREDD is mostly
forgettable, but nevertheless pleasing movie experience.
Copyright © 2001 Dragan Antulov
|