Peter O'Toole has a great role as a former matinee star, a swashbuckling action hero in the style of Errol Flynn. He has since taken to drink and philandering, although he retains enough fame to merit an appearance on the 1954 series "The King Kaiser Show". Kaiser (Joseph Bologna) is an amusing, impulsive comic. His staff includes young comic writer Benjy Stone (Mark Linn-Baker), whose love interest is gopher Jessica Harper.

Linn-Baker is assigned to keep O'Toole out of trouble while the show is in production. Predictably, O'Toole is heedless of Linn-Baker's protestations, instead taking him on a series of drunken adventures in New York.

Mel Brooks produced "My Favorite Year", and the story idea came from his experiences with Errol Flynn when he was a young comic writer on the Sid Caesar show. Richard Benjamin directed instead of Brooks, leading to a more subtle comedy. Still, not all of the scenes work, such as when O'Toole steals a horse, or dines with Linn-Baker's starstruck extended family.

But some of the gags are very funny, especially O'Toole crashing a party by swinging down from a fire hose. O'Toole briefly rejuvenated his career with his performance, earning a Best Actor Academy Award nomination. I also liked the romance between Linn-Baker and Harper, especially the scene where he attempts in vain to teach her how to tell a joke. The off-and-on humor makes for half of a great movie, which is a much larger portion than most comedies have.