|
All-Reviews.com Movie/Video Review
Sidewalks of New York
|
 out of 4
 Review by Harvey Karten No Rating Supplied
|
There are seven million stories in New York, the world's most
exciting city. The six principal ones related by the comic genius
Edward Burns in "Sidewalks of New York" are not unique, not
necessarily encompassing even the most dramatic or exciting of
the lives of the people who inhabit Our Town. But Burns has a
way of making us think they are. Maybe this talent has something to
do with the subject of his movie: sex, or at least love and sex, not
necessarily in that order. Maybe it has to do with the diverse mix
of performers who represent characters of various ages from
youthful adults to middle-aged. Most of all, I think it has to do
with the nature of the their dilemma: their feeling that somehow
there is a void, that life is passing them by, that while they long for
stability, they may be missing some greater adventure or, that
conversely, while they're seeking some greater quest, what
they really lack in their lives is balance.
"Sidewalks of New York," the third film which he has written and
directed and in which he has taken the principal role (he is also
working now on "Ash Wednesday"), is an updated version of Max
Ophuls 1950 film"La Ronde"--a witty account of various people
having affairs, forming a chain that eventually comes full circle.
Burns deliberately eschews the European flair, the particular
sophistication of the work that perhaps inspired it, choosing
instead more American urban take on this universal western
theme But it may not be dismissed as mere fluff. You could well
leave the theater in a somber mood, because after the laughs, the
recognition that your hopes and fears are reflected in the lives of
the people on the screen could lead you to reassess your own
Grand Design. In that sense, "Sidewalks of New York," while less
entertaining than Burns's "She's the One" (about a fella who
married on impulse after discovering that his wife is cheating on
him), and the director's smashing debut "The Brothers McMullen"
(a compelling tale of three brothers with different personalities
living under one roof), carries more gravidas.
Thoroughly character-driven and piloted by mock interviews in a
faux-documentary style, "Sidewalks" deals with six New Yorkers
from various walks (so to speak) of life whose lives and loves
weave and twine and ultimately fall together at the bittersweet
conclusion. Queens-born Tommy (played by writer-director Burns
as the principal character as would Woody Allen were he to direct
the film), is Mr. Outer-Borough, a guy who does not take to self-
disparagement just because he did not grow up in Manhattan but
instead believes that Manhattan would not exist were it not for
people like him. He is living with the slick Carpo (Dennis Farina),
who considers himself Tommy's mentor in love and sex, claiming
500 conquests in the past year, lessons that Tommy does not
necessarily follow when flirting with sixth-grade teacher Maria
(Rosario Dawson), who has been divorced for a year from
Brooklyn doorman Benjamin (David Krumholtz). Perhaps the
most involving of the eternal triangles exists among Griffin
(Stanley Tucci), a Park Avenue dentist married to trophy wife and
real-estate agent Annie (Heather Graham) but conducting an
affair with Iowa-transplant Ashley (Brittany Murphy) who is twenty
years his junior.
As this is Burns's most character-driven movie, you get the
impression that he scours up as much chatter as would an Eric
Rohmer, but there's nothing static in this fast-paced yarn. Burns's
cameraman, Frank Prinzi, switches repeatedly from an
unidentified interviewer who asks mighty personal questions about
sex to each character to the same individuals as they actually live
their love lives--a kind of show-and-tell, tell-and-show merry-go-
roundelay of escapades. Our sympathies go out to all, even to the
conniving, lying, sniveling dentist who flat-out lies to his wife about
his affair with an adorable waitress. If Burns is taking sides, it's
generally with the women: not that he'd go along with Dr. T. that
all women are saints, since after all Ashley must share the blame
as a housebreaker with Griffin, and Maria must come to terms
with her refusal to return Tommy's sincere calls. The film was shot
in just 17 days and though they're tightly scripted, the performers
with almost no exception have the proclivity to say "y'know"
repeatedly, an annoying tic that Burns may have copied from one
of Woody Allen's bad habits.
Men and women might both pick up a few pointers on how to
flirt, whether at the video store, in a museum, in the park, in a
coffee shop, even in the dentist's office. Side characters play their
part to strengthen the film's vision, particularly Michael Leydon
Campbell in the double role as the multi-pierced young band
member Glo and a middle-aged married guy, Harry, who wants to
build a log cabin in the woods (most likely to have a place to take
his women rather than to read Plato under the stars).
Copyright © 2001 Harvey Karten
|
|
|
|


Buy movie posters!
|