| Reviewer Roundup |
| 1. |
 | Harvey Karten |
 | review follows |
 |    |
| 2. |
| Steve Rhodes |
| read the review |
|    |
|
Review by Harvey Karten
3 stars out of 4
I first discussed Filipino culture with my high school class in the
early sixties. We had read Lederer and Burdick's "The Ugly
American," whose title character is a U.S. diplomat in a foreign
land who does not speak the language, and rather than mix with
the people of that underdeveloped country socializes strictly with
fellow Americans living in their cloistered colony. On the other
hand a group of locals in Manila who had just met an American
diplomat expected him to be yet another ugly American but
instead, he spoke with them in Tagalog and at one point said, "I'm
hungry. Where can I get some good adobe and pancit" (the
Filipine national dish)? The locals were amazed and competed
with one another to invite him to their homes for dinner.
In "The Debut," there is a reversal, if you will. The principal
character, despite being a strikingly handsome young man with a
real talent for illustrating comic books, might be called The Ugly
Filipino-American" in that he is ashamed of his culture. In one of
the first-ever Filipino-American films (this made for just $1.5
million), Dante Basco inhabits the role of Ben Mercado, a fellow
who hangs out with an Anglo and a Mexican-American, both of
whom are curious about Filipino culture. They do get a chance to
see it, of course, but if they listened to Ben who repeatedly tries
to escort them out of his house and out of the party his 18-year-
old sister is enjoying they would miss out on a chance to see
some down-home hospitality and some pretty cool dancing.
As in other coming-of-age stories, a parent is at odds with his
adolescent child. Ben's dad Roland (Tirso Cruz) is a postman with
a secret, revealed late into the story. He wants his kid to be
better than he is and to become a doctor, hostile to the lad's
intentions to go to Cal-Tech to be an artist (which dad considers a
hobby unsuitable for the real world). This runs contrary to the
theme in a film opening at about the same time, "Real Women
Have Curves," about a mother who is a seamstress (played by the
inimitable Lupe Ontiveros) who actually discourages her daughter
from dreams of college and incredibly enough wants her to
become a seamstress in a sweatshop, just like her.
"The Debut" is predictable but is no sit-com, thanks to some
remarkably believable acting by Dante Basco in the principal role.
Director Gene Cajayon takes us from the obligatory friction
between father and son to the "good daughter" who insists that
she is fine with a regular birthday party and does not need a
pretentious deb introduction to society. Turning his nose up at his
sister's party, Ben opts to chill with his two pals at a blast
attended by an Anglo girl he thinks he likes. But oh, what he
would have missed if he never returned to his roots. Cajayon
shows us an array of dancing at the party of sister Rose
(Bernadette Balagtas). There's a traditional one done with
clacking bamboo sticks which is in a way like skipping rope in
that the women have to synchronize their steps lest their feet get
caught between the poles. The evening moves from a cha-cha
Filipino style into some exciting break dancing done by a
professional troupe, and ends up with Ben's successfully hitting
on a Filipino girl but not before gangsta wannabe Augusto picks
fights with him for taking away his woman and accuses him of
being a sell-out, a coconut, for having no Filipino friends.
"The Debut," then, is a debut in many ways. First in that this is
among the first Fil-Am films; second in that much of the scenery
is taken up with a birthday party that simulates a low-budget
debutante ball; third in that Ben is making his debut into Filipino
society, finally accepting his racial and national heritage. The
picture somehow lacks the charm of "Real Women Have Curves"
but is heads-and-shoulders superior to the sit-comish but
immensely popular "My Big Fat Greek Wedding." We wish Ben
the best in art school: after all his invested all his savings in first-
year tuition, turning down a scholarship at UCLA, and maybe he'll
even find a field like animation that can show dad that you can
what you want and still make a buck.
Copyright © 2002 Harvey Karten
|