Look at the recent immigration history of the United States
and you'll find that a funny thing has happened on the way to
the money. While the moving of people from the south to the
north after 1945 constituted perhaps the largest push of U.S.
citizens ever from one section to the other, during the last 15 or
20 years the American north has experienced a net loss of
people. Some, retirees largely, have left the frosty New
England states for the Sun Belt of Texas, Florida and Arizona.
Among them are many Puerto Rican-Americans have gone
back to their home island when their working careers ended and
tens of thousands, maybe millions, of African-Americans living
up north returned to the southern states whence they came.
While some in the audience for "The Fighting Temptations" may
not be aware of this historical momentum, they will most
certainly be thinking nostalgically about their childhoods in the
sunny south and, if they had never left the north could actually
be tempted to consider a southward migration some time in the
future.
Why so? I'm guessing that by the way director Jonathan Lynn
manipulates his (willing) audience using a screenplay by
Elizabeth Hunter and Saladin K. Patterson, lots of folks will
leave the theater wondering why they're staying in an areas of
the country that are cold not only in terms of Fahrenheit or
Celsius but frosty as well in interpersonal relationships. The
southerners of "The Fighting Temptations" with one exception
(though she comes around predictably enough) are all jes-folks
while the New Yorkers are portrayed as money-hungry people in
the advertising game out to lie, cheat and sway their targeted
audience into buying their product. "We're going to make a lot
of money," says one cigar-smoking exec in the Madison Avenue
firm. Not "We're going to do good by the people who buy our
drink."
"The Fighting Temptations" takes one such manipulating
executive, Darrin Hill (Cuba Gooding Jr.), a man who lied to his
employer about the schools from which he graduated (Andover
Prep, then Yale), lies to his date about his upbringing (in Monte
Carlo which turns out to be not entirely false), and tailors what
his boss thinks are great ideas to make potential buyers think
they're duds unless they consume the agency's products. By
the end of the picture, Darrin is a genuine human being who
shedsthe confines of suit and tie, embraces the warm people of
his Montecarlo, Georgia home, and even wins the girl he once
romanced when he was five or six years old.
If you're looking for surprises, this is not your picture. If you
don't mind predictability, you like listening to foot-stomping
gospel music (with a dab or two of rap), if you don't mind
watching Cuba Gooding mugging fiercely for the camera
whenever Lynn turns his lens on the energetic comedian, and if
you can delight in the charms of the beautiful and talented
singer Beyonce Knowles, get your tickets now.
"The Fighting Temptations" finds successful hotshot ad exec
Darrin Hill in receipt of a letter urging him to come to his Aunt
Sally's funeral, after which he discovers that Sally left him
$150,000 provided that he gets a church choir into the annual
Gospel Explosion Competition in Columbus, Georgia. As he
looks about the landscape, he finds only untalented would-be
singers, but he also locates people more than folksy in Georgia,
particularly Steve Harvey as the local DJ who smokes, eats and
drinks as he drawls on about the latest events in Montecarlo
("traffic report: there's no traffic"); Paulina (LaTanya Richardson)
as the headstrong church treasurer who wants Darrin out of her
town; Lucius (Mike Epps), who drives Darrin from the train
station with a car whose door opens when it feels like; and best
of all Lilly (Beyonce Knowles), whom he barely recognizes as
the girl he proposed to when she was four years old. How he
builds up his choir to a winning team (using jump-suited
characters from the local jail) forms the crux of the film.
The plot wheels turn, creaky at times, to the inevitable
conclusion; in fact we in the audience are ahead of director
Lynn almost every step of the way. But oh, the music. I was
first introduced to gospel at New York's Bitter End caf when I
was seventeen, and from the first beat of the tambourine I was
hooked on music so exciting, so inspiring from both a religious
and musical point of view that only Mel Gibson could call gospel
a distraction from the true church. The songs are both slow and
melodious like "Swing Low, Sweet Chariot" and at room-busting
volume, a mighty wind that gives Beyonce Knowles her well-
deserved first major role in the movies and shows us city
slickers how much we're missing out of life here in the urban
jungle that's New York.
Copyright © 2003 Harvey Karten