out of 4
All-Reviews.com Movie/Video Review
Garfield: The Movie
Review by Steve Rhodes
2 stars out of 4
Even the perfect choice for a movie's lead can't save a flawed concept. If
you are going to make a movie about the comic strip character Garfield, the
quintessential, laid-back, fat cat, there isn't a better actor to voice the
part than Bill Murray, the actor who should have won the Oscar for his
dead-pan work in LOST IN TRANSLATION.
The problem is that there isn't a comic series less appropriate for a movie
adaptation than Garfield, and I say this as a longtime fan of the strip.
Garfield, with its extremely dry humor, has one good joke per day, which it
GARFIELD: THE MOVIE tries to open up the series and bring it to the big
screen. If you're not a Garfield fan, you'll probably be bored to tears.
And, even if you love the comic, you'll probably find the movie provides a
few smile-worthy moments but no real laughs. The movie's funniest incident
occurs when Garfield is blown so hard into an air-conditioning duct that his
facial impression is stamped into the metal. It's a momentarily nice visual
that is instantly forgotten.
Breckin Meyer and Jennifer Love Hewitt give by-the-numbers readings of
Garfield's owner, Jon, and Jon's would-be girlfriend Liz. Neither actor
appears the least bit interested in their characters. Stephen Tobolowsky
plays Happy Chapman, the story's villain. He says things like, "no dumb,
dirty animal is ever going to get the better of me." Garfield is given just
slightly better lines. When Jon brings home a dog named Odie to be his
second pet, Garfield is aghast. "Please, take this trouser sniffer back,
please," Garfield implores Jon. And, please, 20th Century Fox, don't waste
our time with a sequel, please.
GARFIELD: THE MOVIE runs too long even at just 1:25. It is rated PG for
"brief mild language" and would be acceptable for all ages.
Copyright © 2004 Steve Rhodes
Buy movie posters!