|
Review by Harvey Karten
3½ stars out of 4
Throughout the running of Peter Webber's film "Girl With a
Pearl Earring," no typically cultured member of the audience
could avoid thinking of the words of Hamlet's famous soliloquy,
"'Tis a consummation devoutly to be wished." This time,
however, the consummation is not the gruesome one of death
but of its opposite love a passion that simply cannot be fulfilled.
"The year's most painterly film, broadly shows what life must
have been like in the urban Holland of the mid-17th Century but
more specifically deals with both the ingredients that go into a
fine painting and, more important, a relationship that in a
Hollywood movie would climax in, well, climax, but in this
appropriately restrained treatment simply simmers. A worldly,
33-year-old married man of some artistic repute with a dozen or
so kids in his Catholic family would hardly be expected to carry
out a seduction with a seventeen-year-old who is illiterate,
terminally shy and provincial, but the very impossibility of their
union gives the film its frissons.
Webber, using Tracy Chevalier's 1998 novel adapted for the
screen by Olivia Hetreed who to her credit avoids using voice-
overs that such a novel would ordinarily require performs a
tribute to the Dutch master, Johannes Vermeer by ensuring that
his photographer, Eduardo Serra, casts particularly the outdoor
scenes as though they were themselves paintings executed by
Vermeer.
If you stroll through a museum, New York's Metropolitan,
Madrid's Prado or The Hague's Maurithsuls and wonder what
the artists were thinking as they went about their creative
professions, you're not likely to come up with much that can be
confirmed historically. This is rather the task of the novelist and
film-maker: to employ imagination to convey possibilities. For
example, in the titled work "Girl with a Pearl Earring," whose
fame arises largely from Vermeer's characterization of a young
woman who projects sadness and happiness at the same time,
we want to know particularly what is going through the mind of
the subject who is sitting for the artistic creation. This film
suggests that very background.
"Girl" opens on Griet (Scarlett Johansson), plunged at the age
of 17 into what is for practical purposes an alien culture when
her father, a painter of tiles, goes blind. Lacking education, she
must make her way as a maid, putting her into the Vermeer
household, a tumultuous residence whose noise levels,
furnished by a large numbers of children (think of Shawn Levy's
movie "Cheaper by the Dozen"), requires the man of the house
to isolate himself in his studio to concentrate on his work. Timid
to the point of looking away from people who address her,
pursued by Pieter (Cillian Murphy), the son of the local butcher
and later lusted after by the rich patron of the arts, Van Ruijven
(Tom Wilkerson), Griet (pronounced Greet) unwittingly causes
rampant jealousies when the painter's wife, the neurotically
bawling Catharina (Essie Davis), correctly assesses the erotic
power the teen has over her husband. When Catharina is
ultimately betrayed by her own mother, the severe Maria Thins
(Judy Parfitt), the largely sedate film comes to a maddening
climax.
"Girl With a Pearl Earring" is filmed alternately with green and
yellow filters as Webber opens us to the surroundings: the
woods, the filthy canal, the teeming marketplace populated by
chickens, pigs, ducks, and one lovable dog. In fact absent the
animals, the marketplace could be one in Amsterdam today,
selling herrings, or the cheese market in the town of Gouda.
Picturesque as olde Holland may be, this is not the kind of place
that most comfortable Westerners would choose to
spend a week's vacation, given the odors carried by the canal in
a place that has scant ideas of human sanitation. A maid's life
in such a locale is not a happy one, particularly given the
hostility a pretty young woman would inevitably arouse by her
mere presence, her smooth-faced looks and callow charm
arousing the attentions of Vermeer and his wealthy patron, the
enmity of the painter's wife and twelve-year-old daughter, and
the surprising turnaround of the severe mother-in-law with her
Elizabethan collar and her perverse encouragement of the
Johannes-Griet bond.
Scarlett Johansson is carving out a place for herself as a
performer who has already matched up to the comedic skills of
Bill Murray in one my top ten picks this year, "Lost in
Translation," while Colin Firth does a surprising turn as a
conflicted artist who is unable to let loose with his usual,
assertively romantic style. Alexandre Desplat's John-Cage-like
music adds to the baroque ambiance of the piece.
Copyright © 2003 Harvey Karten
|