|
Review by Harvey Karten
3 stars out of 4
Director Douglas McGrath ("Emma"), who tackled the nearly-
impossible task of reducing Dickens's popular novel, "Nicholas
Nickleby," to just 130 minutes, believes that the author is the
world's greatest storyteller. Why so? In his introduction to the
Penguin paperback, released at the time of the opening of his new
movie, he cites plot, character, dialogue, and Dickens's obsession
with making the world a kinder place. Storyteller, no doubt, when
you consider that England's most important Nineteenth Century
novelist is concerned not only with keeping our eye on the central
theme but on shooting the breeze with stories within stories
whether or not any of them has anything to do with the book's
spine.
You couldn't convince me of Dickens's worth when I was back in
prep school, a snobbish place based on the British idea of
education, which consisted of calling classes "forms," the
cafeteria "the commons," and eschewed the kinds of books we
wanted to read such as Orwell's 99-page "Animal Farm" rather
than the 1,000-page, small-print "Nicholas Nickleby." Now that
I've advanced in years I probably would still opt to do book reports
on "Animal Farm," but I've come to appreciate the delectably long-
winded Dickensians tracts especially when the thousand pages
can be reduced to a comfortably brief whirl of celluloid.
Critics, pretended that they've all seen the Royal Shakespeare
Company's nine-hour stage version of what we in prep school
called "Nick-Nick," are likely to say that none of the half-dozen
movie versions (dating back to 1903) can compare. Nonetheless
Mr. McGrath's film is a pure holiday delight and, I dare say, fit for
a pleasant diversion on the big screen 'most any time of the year.
In whittling down the book, eliminating minor character whose
names are so peculiar you'd think that the author was spoofing his
society-Gregsby, Graymarsh, Cobbey, Mobbs, Belvawney,
Grudden, Curdle, Pyke, Knag, Mulberry Hawk, Bobster,
Petowker; but keeping others with equally quaint names like
Wackford Squeers, Newman Noggs, Smike and Bray-McGrath
McGrath emphasizes the comic touches to keep Mr. Dickens
smiling in his grave. After all, you can't better society by some
dull preaching: you have to keep the audience in their seats first,
keep 'em smiling and laughing. Then throw in the compassionate
liberalism.
Thematically, Dickens is most concerned with the glories of
family, but not in the banal and insincere concept of politicians
like Dan Quayle but in the idea of the extended family, the family
of human beings rather than simply those who blood types we
share. At the center of the book and the movie is the title
character (Charlie Hunnam), happily living with his sister Kate
(Romola Garai) and mother (Stella Gonet) in a Devonshire cottage
surrounded by green, then becoming as lost as an Appalachian
coal miner suddenly thrust alone into New York's Rockefeller
Center. When Nickleby's father (Andrew Havill) dies when the boy
is nineteen, Nicholas goes to London with his sister Kate and
mother, hoping to get aid from Mr. Nickleby's brother Ralph
(Christopher Plummer)-a moneylender and scrooge who proves to
be the chief villain of the drama. Ralph gets Nicholas a job as
assistant to the one-eyed Wackford Squeers (Jim Broadbent),
who operates a terrible boarding school in Yorkshire into which
cast-aways are deposited, starved and beaten. When Squeers
and his wife (Juliet Stevenson) beat the dickens out of one
crippled castaway, Smike (Jamie Bell), Nicholas "adopts" the lad
and runs away with him in search of adventure. At this point the
road-and-buddy movie begins with adventures designed to restore
Nicholas to a sense of family coupled with a need to avenge
himself on his uncle. While the marriage of Nicholas to one
Madeline Bray (Anne Hathaway) and of his sister Kate to a decent
guy of her own are inevitable in a holiday story that must have a
happy ending, Nicholas enjoys particularly delightful times on the
way especially with a theatrical troupe headed by Vincent
Crummles (Nathan Lane), including his wife (Dame Edna
Everage), and a Highland dancer played by the always amusing
Alan Cummings.
"Nicholas Nickleby" could be the breakthrough performance of
handsome Charlie Hunnam, whom we left not so long ago for
dead, stoned at the hands of Katie Holmes in Stephen Gaghan's
"Abandon." The trouble is that Nicholas is such a one-
dimensional sweet guy that Mr. Hunnam does not get a chance
from the script to strut his stuff. Sure, he raises his fist once
against a rich investor, Newman Noggs (Tom Courtenay) who
insulted his sister by hitting on her shamelessly during a
performance of "Romeo and Juliet," and he gets the drop on the
schoolmaster, giving him a whipping as an object lesson, but for
the most part he's given to squeaky-clean moralism and
Shakespearean statements to his love-at-first-sight girl friend. As
a result, we're drawn more to the two villains, both of whom turn in
rollicking performances. Jim Broadbent's role as sadistic
schoolmaster gets him to ham things up, one eye closed as he
had lost his vision early on both physically and morally, helping
him to eat up the scenery whenever he appears. Best of all,
Christopher Plummer, dignified as a robber baron must be, has
the juicy job of turning from the moneyed head of his extended
family and one who gives "family values" a bad name, to his
comeuppance when everything caves in at once.
I'd like to think that Douglas McGrath's film will encourage his
audience to go out and get the Penguin book, but then, we're a
fast-paced, Cliff-Notes addicted society more likely to pick up the
latest self-help book from Barnes and Noble than anything written
before the year 2000. That being the case, you can't go wrong by
taking in Dickens-light. "Nicholas Nickleby" gives us all the moral
vision, the rich characters, the love of storytelling that Charles
Dickens has willed to his family of millions.
Copyright © 2002 Harvey Karten
|