|
Review by Harvey Karten
3½ stars out of 4
A temporary casualty of the World Trade Center destruction on
September 11, 2001, "The Quiet American" was put on a shelf
presumably because some in the U.S. might be in no mood for a
story critical of our country's role in Vietnam. While the United
States does not come out smelling of Chanel, one could hardly
take umbrage at a movie whose critical tone does not begin to
compare with that of the extraordinary activities of peace groups
throughout the nation during the late 1960s and early 1970s
opposing America's role in the Southeast Asian country. Perhaps
only those under the age of thirty-seven, Americans who had not
been born when the Vietnam War ended in 1975 and who to this
day may have heard of President Johnson only in their history
classes, would be offended. Nonetheless with film studios so
attuned to the public mood that even a movie about a sniper had
to be temporarily shelved because of a real-live duo of thrill-
seeking gunmen, we need not wonder that "The Quiet American"
can be released here only now.
And how lucky we are that the well-deserved reviews from the
Toronto Film Festival led to its opening in the U.S., because Philip
Noyce's adaptation of Graham Greene's slim but powerful novel
provides not only an eye-catching probe of French and American
foreign policy during the early 1950's but provides a platform for
the superb talent of Michael Caine in the role of a British journalist
covering the war.
To this day, even Americans who are aware of U.S. involvement
in Vietnam may know only vaguely that the French were there
before, seeking to maintain their hold on that poverty-stricken
nation for no other reason, one would guess, than maintaining the
prestige of colonial expansion. As Britain was neutral, the
coverage of the war provided by English journalist Thomas Fowler
(Michael Caine), seemed secure enough but his position in
spacious housing depended on continued financial support from
London. Fowler may not have grown to love his assignment, but
he was in no mood to return to his unhappy marriage in London
now that he enjoys the love of his beautiful mistress, Phuong (Hai
Yen. Trouble arises when an idealistic American Aid worker,
Alden Pyle (Brendan Fraser), introduced himself to the reporter,
and falls in love at first sight with Fowler's girlfriend-who to
Fowler's joy rejects the younger man's proposal of marriage.
Things are not what they seem in love and war, however, and
the romantic triangle and the political and military activities in
Saigon and in neighboring villages will lead to revelations of
secrets, betrayals, and murder.
If Mr. Fraser seems ill-at-ease and stiff, his style may be what
attracted director Philip Noyce to the engaging American actor
since, after all, Fraser's character must convey what was then
America's naive optimism about world affairs. Though Pyle is a
more dangerous fellow than he seems, he exudes silliness more
than arrogance when he proposes to Phuong while standing
inches away from his older, wiser rival. Michael Caine delivers his
signature cynicism with a twinkle in his eye when, observing the
proposal of the young man asks him, "Shouldn't you be down on
one knee?" Christopher Hampton and Robert Schenkkan's
literate script takes us beyond the dumbed-down version of "The
Quiet American" from its 1958 adaptation into a thoroughly three-
dimensional portrait of the land as it fought the French fifty years
ago, right up to America's increasing involvement even before the
French were finally defeated at the Battle of Dien Bien Phu in
1954.
This is, as the production notes state, the Vietnam movie that
has not been made, a now subtle, now explosive struggle for
power in both the sexual domain and the political arena.
Copyright © 2002 Harvey Karten
|