| Reviewer Roundup |
| 1. |
 | Harvey Karten |
 | review follows |
 |    |
| 2. |
| Steve Rhodes |
| read the review |
|    |
|
Review by Harvey Karten
3 stars out of 4
Not every American who goes to Rome can have the luck of
Lizzie McGuire, who meets a handsome rock singer and is
transformed from a klutzy team to a confident woman. In fact the
typical tourists in Rome and Florence, having been bored by the
Sistine Chapel, probably do not bother traveling south to Sicily
where they can likewise yawn at the Roman ruins at Siracusa.
But if these travelers would continue south yet again, past the
island of Malta to tiny Lampedusa in the Pelagie belt and could
somehow be accepted by the insular group of people who live
there folks who'd as likely look forward to journeying to Florence
and I would be likely to put Baghdad on my itinerary--they just
might find enough material for a novel.
Emanuele Crialese, who was born in Rome, graduated from
New York University, and wrote and directed "Respiro" entirely in
Lampedusa, knew he could evoke a tale from the folks who live
there. What's more he had the advantage of exploiting an Italian
legend, one that deals with an unconventional woman who got the
local tongues wagging, all agreeing that the high-spirited femme
was downright nuts and needed regular injections to be
tranquilized. The woman was not unaware of the local gossip, but
she had other ideas on how to feel at peace with the world: she'd
explore the healing powers of the sea, where she could leave her
anxieties behind and gain rest. In fact "Respiro," the title of this
film, means "a place of rest" or "a pause."
"Respiro" is not the sort of pic that would be attended by fans of
"Matrix," "X-Men" or "2 Fast 2 Furious," given its tranquil setting,
upset now and then by the gyrations of the town's misfit and the
fights between two rival groups of teens and sub-teens whose idea
of fun in a place that offered no healthy amusements for the young
is to punch one another out and humiliate the adversaries by
stripping them of their clothing. The principal focus is on Grazia
(Valeria Golino), who does not feel fulfilled cleaning fish all day
with a group of woman while her husband, Pietro (Vincenzo
Amato) is out on his boat making his daily catch while flinging a
few fish to the kids--who include Grazia's favorite son Pasquale
(Francesco Casisa), and whose younger brother, Filippo (Filippo
Pucillo, takes after his assertive dad. Grazia relieves her boredom
by swimming topless, waving to the local fishermen and causing
such a scandal in the town that her family is preparing to send her
to Milan for psychiatric treatment. Grazia, not one to be mellowed
out under the care of some Nurse Ratched, has her own plans,
which involve conspiring to hide from the town so long that she will
be given up for dead.
"Respiro" meanders about, Crialese more concerned with giving
his audience the island's zeitgeist than carving out a powerful
story of heroes and villains, though he does evoke one of the
lovely myths that have been passed down through the generations
about a woman just like the free-spirited Grazia. We see how the
boys fill the days by fighting, by cooking birds they have caught
and fish that have been tossed to them, and taking their chances
on a lottery that could win them a cool set of electric trains. The
girls flirt perhaps with the local police whose principal job is to
make sure that no more than one passenger is riding at one time
on any motorized scooter. Grazia is a pretty woman, not the sort
who takes kindly to her provincial environs, yet paradoxically goes
ballistic at the thought of moving to sophisticated Milan even for a
short time. Valeria Golino does a lovely job inhabiting the role, a
Neopolitan performer who has been featured in diverse fare such
as Mike Figgis' "Hotel," Rodrigo Garcia's "Things You Can Tell
Just By Looking At Her," and who appeared opposite Tom Cruise
in "Rain Man." "Respiro" played the festival circuit at Telluride and
Toronto and won the Critics Week Award at Cannes last year.
Copyright © 2003 Harvey Karten
|