After fighting for the remote control that they have just received from
a mysterious television repairman (Don Knotts), teenage siblings, David
(Tobey Maguire), and Jennifer (Reese Witherspoon), are transported into
the t.v. set and find themselves on the black-and-white 50's sitcom,
"Pleasantville," taking over the places of the children in the show, Bud
and Mary Sue. Their parents in the show are, as are the rest of the
parents, the type that you might see on "Father Knows Best," or "Leave
It to Beaver," with a housewife (Joan Allen) who does all of the cooking
and cleaning, and a husband (William H. Macy) who goes to work during
the day, only to return by saying, "Honey, I'm home," and to find his
dinner waiting for him in the kitchen. Since David is a fan of the show,
he can always tell which episode is occurring at a certain time, and
urges Jennifer not to do anything that would disrupt their routine.
Soon, however, Jennifer has had sex with one of the boys from school, a
thing that no one in the show has previously even known about, and as
many of the people in Pleasantville become open to new, fresh ideas,
parts of the fictional world begin to subtly turn to real colors,
including the people themselves.
If there was one word to describe Gary Ross' new fantasy,
"Pleasantville," it would be the word, magical, and the less said about
the story, the better. The film is a wholeheartedly original motion
pcture, visually beautiful, and, while it starts off as a sort of
"fish-out-of-water" story, it quickly turns it something far more
meaningful and mature than expected. Although basically a comedy,
"Pleasantville" also contains many serious moments, including one scene
in which David helps his mother, played splendidly by Allen, who has
turned to real colors, and frightened at the prejudices of the other
people in the town, to cover up her face with gray makeup.
One of the big treats of "Pleasantville" is the way that the film very
gradually begins to transform things into technicolor. At first, it may
just be small things in the background, such as a clock or a flower, and
it is quite entertaining picking out all of the delicate changes. As far
as I can tell, "Pleasantville" is the first film to actually blend
black-and-white and color together in the same frame, and it is never
less than convincing and always gorgeous and strangely poetic to look
at. Credit certainly must go to production designer Jeannine Oppewall
and cinematographer John Lindley, for creating a whole new, unexpected
world.
"Pleasantville" easily could have been the fantasy of this generation,
just like "The Wizard of Oz," but there are a few minor problems that
ultimately hold it back from being a downright great film. One problem
is the Don Knotts character, who has no point in the story but to give
the kids the remote so they would be put inside "Pleasantville." We
never really get to know who he is, or what his goal was. Witherspoon,
who has proven herself a fine actress, and doesn't disappoint here, is
nonetheless underused, and seems to all but disappear from the middle
section of the picture. And my last minor quibble is that one of the
climactic scenes set in the courtroom owes more than a little to, "To
Kill a Mockingbird," right down to the way the building looks.
These slight distractions take very little away from "Pleasantville,"
however, because as previously mentioned, the film is a magical
experience. It contains enchanting, one-of-a-kind images, a memorable,
Oscar-worthy music score by Randy Newman, and then, and this is the big
surprise for a mainstream film, it actually adds profundity and realism
to what, on the surface, might appear to be merely a 50's sitcom satire.
Copyright © 2000 Dustin Putman