"Practical Magic," is a film that is so misguided in so many ways that
it makes you wonder how such talented and high-profile actors would even
get involved in an embarrassing clap-trap like this one.
The film stars Sandra Bullock and Nicole Kidman as Sally and Gillian
Owens, two sisters whose family comes from a long line of witches,
spanning back 200 years. At the start, their parents die when they are
still children, and they go to live with their two zany aunts (Stockard
Channing and Dianne Wiest). Switch to the present day, Gillian, who is
the stronger, more rebellious sibling, leaves home, and meets up with a
dark, abusive guy (Goran Visjnic), while Sally stays in their hometown,
meets and falls in love with a sweet, caring man, has two children, and
then is devastated when her husband is hit by a truck and killed (come
to think of it, she's not too devastated since she gets over it in about
two minutes). When Gillian calls Sally to come get her after having
another abusive spat with Visjnic, they accidentally murder him, and in
desperation, bury the body in the backyard of their aunts' house. Add to
this wildly convoluted story subplots involving the dead rising and an
exorcism, not to mention a spattering of "light-hearted whimsy," and you
have a pretty good idea how messy "Practical Magic" is.
After seeing the film, I reflected that there was not even one scene, or
element, that I liked or enjoyed. It is a comedy, to be sure, but all of
the humor falls astoundingly flat, and the occasional dramatic moments
are the least bit touching. It is not charming or entertaining in any
way. And then to top it off, we've got this dark, but bird-brained story
of an evil spirit taking over Gillian's body. Whatever.
The characters are handled terribly, and actually, most of the actors do
not have the fortune of even getting to be what you could call a
character. There is no reason why Channing and Wiest should have decided
to be in this film, and in every scene involving them, they are always
standing side-by-side. No attempt is made to flesh them out into actual
people. The same goes for Aidan Quinn, as a handsome police
investigator, who has the misfortune of being the romantic lead opposite
Bullock, even though he comes into it at around the 70-minute mark, and
once again, there is no attempt to develop their relationship, or his
character, in any way. In fact, every line of dialogue in the film is in
service of moving the plot along, rather than getting to know the people
saying the lines. I should have know I was headed for trouble during the
opening credits, when I found out the screenplay was written by the
deeply hated Akiva Goldsman, who managed to destroy the "Batman" series
with "Batman Forever" and "Batman and Robin."
"Practical Magic" is directed by Griffin Dunne, primarily an actor, who
last year made the contrived, clumsy romance, "Addicted to Love," with
Meg Ryan and Matthew Broderick. I disliked that movie quite a bit, but
since "Practical Magic" is even worse, that can only give you a taste of
what a talentless filmmaker he is. I'd tell him to quit while he's
ahead, but in these last two years, he's ultimately already buried
himself.
Copyright © 1998 Dustin Putman