It's terribly unfortunate that "Stir of Echoes," tautly written and directed
by David Koepp (who made one of 1996's unsung treasures, "The Trigger
Effect"), should be released little more than a month after "The Sixth
Sense," which is still going strong at the box office. These two films are
undoubtedly going to be compared (judging from practically all of my fellow
audience members last night), and although they have eerily similar
storylines, "Stir of Echoes" is more of a straightforward psychological
horror film, while "The Sixth Sense" is closer to a psychological drama.
Additionally, while "The Sixth Sense" had a shocker of an ending that
undoubtedly has been one of the major factors in its recent repeat business,
"Stir of Echoes" is more conventional and predictable in its final twist. And
where "The Sixth Sense" was disturbing, "Stir of Echoes" is just plain scary.
I have a feeling most viewers are going to come away unimpressed because of
the unavoidable similarities, and will foolishly forget to judge this film on
its own respectable merits.
Adapted from a novel by Richard Matheson that was written some forty years
ago, "Stir of Echoes" opens with a cute six-year-old boy named Jake (Zachary
David Cope) who is taking a bath. He is speaking directly at the screen, but
we immediately have a feeling someone else is there. Finally, he asks, "Does
it hurt to be dead?" Apparently Jake sees the ghosts of dead people, but
unlike "The Sixth Sense," this young child isn't the focus of the picture.
Instead, Tom Witzy (Kevin Bacon), a Chicago lineman, is our protagonist. Jake
is his son, and Maggie (Kathryn Erbe), whom has just discovered she is six
weeks pregnant, is his hard-working wife. One night while at a party with
their closest friends, Tom convinces Maggie's New-Age sister, Lisa (Illena
Douglas), to try and hypnotize him. It unexpectedly works, and before long,
Tom is seeing things he wouldn't normally see, including a deceased teenage
girl (Jenny Morrison) in his house who happens to have been missing for the
last six months. Seeking help from Lisa, she tells him that, while he was
under hypnosis, she told him that after he awoke, his mind will remain clear
and free, like an opened door. She didn't expect it to work, but it did, and
the only way to stop it is for Tom to somehow find a way to help this girl he
sees.
"Stir of Echoes" isn't a perfect film by any stretch of the imagination, but
in the thick, atmospheric mood it conjures up, it is a terrifically eerie
domestic horror-drama, and is not only effective on a technical level, but is
impressive in its portrayal of a struggling working-class family. Kevin Bacon
and, especially, Kathryn Erbe (1997's "Dream With the Fishes"), are top-notch
and exceedingly believable as a loving married couple who nonetheless have
their fair share of problems. After Tom is hypnotized and starts seeing
ghastly visions, he is completely taken over by his desire to solve this
mystery of the disappearing girl whom he has seen lurking in his house, and
instead of Maggie not being understanding, she instead believes what Tom
says, and aside from being a little worried by what he is going through, does
not try to stop his pursuit. Bacon and Erbe are not traditional Hollywood
stars like Tom Cruise and Julia Roberts, and therefore, are easier to relate
to and always plausible as a struggling couple who have to work overtime at
their jobs just to make ends meet.
In a masterfully-done, entrancing sequence, Tom is hypnotized by Lisa, but
instead of watching him, we instead see what he sees, starting from his view
as he closes his eyes into darkness. Lisa tells him to visualize being in an
empty movie theater, and so, we, as audience members, are watching a movie
screen from inside a theater, which is also showing a movie screen in a
theater. Telling him to move closer and closer to the screen as a fuzzy word
in black letters pops up on the screen, we begin to float closer and closer
to the front of the theater until we see that the word is "sleep." Never
before have I seen a hypnotism scene as mesmerizing and brilliantly-construed
as this one. Truthfully, this set-piece, and another in which Tom wakes up
from a nightmarish dream only to quickly discover he is reliving what he has
just dreamt, are worth the full price of admission alone, just to see them on
the big screen.
Having loads of fun with her small role as Maggie's sister, Lisa, Illeana
Douglas (1995's "To Die For," her last great character) is a delight, but
rarely used to her full advantage in feature films. Funny and enjoyably
offbeat, Douglas gets to utter the best line in the film: While talking to
Maggie about Tom's visions of the girl, she remarks, "I wouldn't be worried
about him seeing another girl, although the fact that she's dead gives one
pause." Also of note are Jenny Morrison (1994's "Intersection"), who is truly
poignant in the last half of the film when we flash back to see what really
happened to her missing character, and Liza Weil, remarkable in 1998's
"Whatever," as Morrison's grieving teenage sister, Debbie.
If the resolution of "Stir of Echoes" does not live up to its obviously
frightful full potential (and it doesn't), what comes before is both
involving and appropriately gritty. The music score, by James Newton Howard,
and unsettling use of whispers and ghostly sound effects, successfully
compliment and foreshadow the off-kilter frame-of-mind that Tom is put into,
and director David Koepp proves once again that he is a director with a knack
for creating almost unbearably tense situations that revolve around
realistically-written characters. "Stir of Echoes" isn't as good as "The
Sixth Sense," but why should it need to be? Both films are fully capable of
standing on their own two feet, and "Stir of Echoes" really is a
spinetinglingly good horror film.
Copyright © 2000 Dustin Putman